Interpreting the Book of JOK(e)
A Brief Note on Jasun Horsley’s The Gospel of Job
Guest post from Guido Preparata
It is with pleasure and a sense of hopefulness that I write these impressions of Jasun Horsley’s latest tour de force, The Gospel of Job.
It has been now some time since Jasun has actively trodden on the highroad of biblical exegesis in search of a personal decryption of the Bible’s Book of Job. The latter is a classical quarry that has been heavily mined, as we know; a topic that has exercised the mind and soul of the greats —Goethe, of course, first comes to mind, then Jung, and many others—its classicalness being in the final analysis accounted for by its paramount concern with theodicy. Theodicy: the problem of reconciling the ongoing infliction of violence and injustice (“evil”) by men on other men with the putative benevolence of the divine Creator of those very men—philosophically speaking, the mother of all problems.
For Jasun, the Hebrew Bible, and especially the Book of Job, is a text as good as any to start with for investigating this question. He takes the western canon in stride and does not cavil whether the Bible is literally the word of God —assuming that a god such as the Bible’s “Yahweh” is real—or if “The Book” ought to be contrasted with scripture encoded in other parts of the world. Jasun takes the conservatively aesthetic way out. All stimulating fiction —and especially metafiction (i.e., fiction that openly acknowledges it is a story)—is words written by inspired individuals; and that is all we need to seed our discussion. It just so happens, says Jasun, that skryers and scribes possessed by supernatural forces so profoundly as, say, the Hebrew prophets themselves, are impossible to find nowadays. And that explains why, despite rare (modern) exceptions—witness, for instance, the adoration for Dostoyevski—the Bible remains to this day an inexhaustible fount of discussion and speculation. It’s like the Beatles’ records still commanding top-tier prices, right alongside today’s contemporary chart-toppers; or being willing to pay top-dollars to see The Stones or The Who in their eighties playing live: they just don’t make the good stuff as they used to…So Job.
From the outset, Jasun makes it clear that he resonates with the Christic vibration: “there is no other context for God, Christ […] that is real” he writes, “unless it be the depth of despair, human misery, and spiritual desolation, from which only faith can save us. No light without darkness. […] Life is not meant to be a funfair.” In Jasun’s progression, we thus have a profound receptiveness to the warmth of the Redeemer, a comforting warmth which appears to be invoked from a primal locus of pain; for pain is the experiential foundation of living and feeling. And that is just the way it is. And on top of this problematic state of affairs lies this inscrutable, intimidating “God.” This God who, say, in violent retort, scourges Job’s plaintive remonstrances. “Where were you when I created the Universe?” God asks Job, who, cowered, replies he does not know, which, in turn elicits Yahweh’s cocky closure: “That’s what I thought.” The scene has the texture of a Scorsese movie—the sort in which, an inch away from “waxing” him, the Don graciously silences the lowly mafioso who had dared to protest. Problematic indeed, all of it. And yet, can one live without Don Vito Corleone? Bullying as He may be, this is still His circus. Are we then His monkeys? Why, and what for?
Can one live without God? Jasun does not wonder whether God exists, but rather whether “can anything exist that is not God? And if so, to what end?” Of course, the scourging and the pain—evil, in short—immediately rears its head; and being logically forced to attribute it (all) to God (to Whom else?), men inevitably experience “cognitive problems.” More than problematic, the prospects of such additive considerations appear maddening. What is one to do, then, in order to preserve his sanity and keep the pain at bay or, alternatively, interiorize it with a view to achieving some higher form of trusting serenity?
Possibly, we may reinterpret it all, yet again, differently. What if, in the beginning, rather than the mysterious nondescript “Word,” there was . . . a joke? “Maybe the Bible,” says Jasun, “should be considered the joke of God?” A game of mirrors and parodies, in which laws and commandments are erected only to be systematically torn down and derided in some kind of never-ending loop: The Book of Job and Ecclesiastes, e.g., famously do this labor of dismantlement, insinuating doubt as to the world’s, God’s, putative fairness and, apparently, letting cynicism thereby fester —a cynicism which does not accord with the righteous letter of the devotional injunctions contained in the scripture. The animadversions on God are then bookended with moral exhortations, and the perplexity circles back to the beginning for another round of doubt and incertitude. And for Jasun that is exactly the labor of redirection the joke is meant to induce. Not to become resigned and cynical, but rather, by grasping the irony, to achieve a higher sense of what it actually means to be religious and have faith.
This all seems to mean that this Jewish saga, culminating in Christ, is in fact a preparation for the realization that the question of faith, ethos, and human behavior in general appears to be confined to the realm of victimhood and sufferance: there, and there only will one find Jesus the Savior. Yes, God the curmudgeonly Father is “responsible” for the obstacles and the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune that cause all the pain in the first place, but He is also the one who gave the sufferers his son Christ to overcome it all—and this apportionment, however disquieting as it may look, is nonetheless enough, far than more than enough interior space within which to glue back together the shards of our dereliction and refashion faith, and life, anew. And if I interpret his vision correctly, this seems indeed for Jasun the greatest gift one could receive; the source of eternal beginnings: a “victory over the world.”
But the intended consequences of the joke do not stop here, because we have not yet said what the drive of one’s faith presently becomes once the irony has been discerned. The change here affects the sense of self: a new “I” emerges. And as I, like Job, defy, I gain further understanding; and as I see things more clearly, my self is thereby potentiated. I ultimately intuit that living is not a question of seeking an escape from God’s mad circus, but that we have to remain in the circus and stand fast, defying, resisting only to comprehend that, again, we always had God, Whom we shouldn’t have thought of outflanking, because, in the end, we were given Christ, and He and the Son are the same thing. It is pieces of the same puzzle, and in time, we complete it, with newfound peace, to see the bigger picture. We defy; the “I” expands; and adding the “I” to “defy” we “deify,” reaching the station we had questioningly anticipated, wondering originally whether on the one hand we could live without God, and whether all resolves itself into “God” on the other. We cannot help but “clutching” at Him.
The LORD was with us in all we did, apparently, and so we prospered. We learned the hard way that having the LORD with one does not require prosperity as its proof (p. 124).
In the final segment of The Gospel of Job, Jasun draws significant parallels between his own personal and familial vicissitudes and the troubles suffered by the Job of the homonymous book. These singular connections cogently account for the deep affinity Jasun has developed for the biblical narrative. Clearly, these classic texts owe their endurance to their echoing the shattering heart-breaks multitudinous strands of humanity have been experiencing for millennia. And Jasun’s effort is yet another poignant testimony of the Bible’s abiding narrational appeal.
Going back to the aforementioned “disquieting apportionment”—that is, of evil to an ineffable region mysteriously presided by God, and faith, on the other hand, to the passionate, all-too-tangible realm of Christ— Jasun nonetheless feels the need not to leave God’s ineffable business, i.e. “evil,” wholly unbroached. “God,” he writes, is not “the concept by which we measure pain,” but rather “the reality through which we transform suffering into grace.” Assume, then, that God is real. It thus follows that “if any evil exists ‘out there’ in the world, it is only insofar as the world ‘out there’ is fundamentally unreal.” In this fashion, Jasun conjoins Christ’s redemptive mission with Buddha’s advertence to the chaos of the world as a byproduct of illusion.
Jasun does concede that, intellectually, this theodicean affair is unsolvable: there appears to be no argument whereby one may reconcile the problem of evil with the existence of a good, all-seeing God. Nor does Jasun appear interested, like some adepts of “magick,” in turning the game on its head by redefining “good” and “evil” so as to propose an altogether different tray of possibilities: he would among other things, most likely lose Jesus thereby.
So, what does all this add up to?
God may value human beings, but not the things that human beings value […]. “Without me,” [God seems to be intimating], “you have nothing. With me, you need nothing.”
“This,” Jasun concludes, “is the lesson of Job.”
Like Job, says Jasun, we have little choice but to persist either in blind obedience or frantic rebellion (or both) on our way to wisdom. The Void is there for us to occupy it through struggle so as to orient its field towards love.
The Struggle.
Jasun wonders: Could it be our fate, then, that in our spiritual infancy we are meant to agitate as God’s “Promethean” and “wily” rivals; to antagonize Him so pugnaciously as to make our inevitable “surrender” all the more delectable?
And on this note the reflection ends, with a promise for all of us, that so long as we believe, we will prevail—with grace, that is; filled with peace, with love, the love of a difficult father, with hobbies different from ours,1 yet who never ceases to love us. And the extent of that love can be contemplated in the dazzling luminescence of Jesus himself. A sub-emanation of which may take the form of “a palpable sense of a loving intelligence” such as Jasun felt around him moons ago when, solo, he crossed the Straits of Gibraltar on his way to freedom (and the unknown) via Tangiers.
This last vision reminds me of a diary entry by Eugène Ionesco, in which he reminisces how an Orthodox priest, witnessing during confession a young Ionesco in agony over the defilements of evil and sin, summarily dismissed each and every one of the youth’s moral derailments enjoining him, instead, only to believe, and do nothing else but to persist in believing.
So far, this seems the only path we can travel on. Because the mind cannot crack the mystery of evil, says Jasun, we can only trust our body and soul to do it —and, according to him, experience, bodily and emotional, has indeed shown us that interiorly, this can be done. The heart will take us there, past the lacerations, the ensuing fights, the defiance, and the bold sallies against the Father. In due time, the body will announce the surrender; the sensing of the warmth, that He always was there. Just believe. Live, in pain, to believe, eventually.
It has been a pleasure for me to read Jasun’s The Gospel of Job because I derive comfort from seeing some of us bravely struggling with the forbidding asperities of theodicy. The ongoing intellectual fight with this “monster” (theodicy) keeps us strong. The hopefulness comes from appreciating the creative ways—and Jasun’s meditation is a poignant instance of this—in which one is (conceptually) capable of shaping life’s antagonism into a universal message of love.
So, all is good on our(investigative) front. Jasun is healthy and pushing forth. Let the rest of us get back on the road and follow his lead.
Guido G. Preparata,
Città di Castello, Oct. 2026
1 What does He tinker with in his leisurely time? I wonder.