How to Meet Evil (A Tale of Two Cats)

How to Meet Evil (A Tale of Two Cats)
(Art by Michelle Horsley)

The first incident I will recount occurred in the summer of 2001, in Guatemala. I have referenced it many times and even recounted it in full on a couple of occasions (including in an unpublished memoir). It characterizes the low point of my “Lucifer period.” It is an act of violence that (as is always the case) felt justified at the time—though now it seems to me symptomatic of a deep neurotic complex.

Even, as we’ll see, a mother complex. (In many ways, my Lucifer complex was a mother complex, which suggests that all of these recent posts have been circling around the same target.)

The second incident occurred early this year, late summer of 2026, making it exactly 25 years after the first. It came on the tail end (no pun intended) of my Lucifer 2.0 reworking, with which I hoped to formalize the end of my Lucifer pact and usher in a new phase, a final phase, out of darkness, and into the light.

In both cases, I was faced with the identical problem. A stray cat was entering my house and eating my cats’ food. In both cases, I first attempted terror tactics.

In 2001, I caught the cat (a ginger) and gave it a mild thrashing, hoping to deter it from ever returning. In 2026, I cornered the cat (part Siamese, thick-furred) and “water-boarded” it—or rather, sprayed it with a water bottle repeatedly while it cowered helplessly. On both occasions, my method failed; both cats came back within 24 hrs.

It is here that my tactics drastically diverged. In 2001, I doubled down. Once again, I chased the cat around the house, cornered it in the bathroom, and captured it with a towel. Carried away by murderous rage at having my territory invaded, I then proceeded to throttle it.

Dimly, I realized I was going to kill the animal—not merely frighten it, but finish it off. I was both in and out of control. With hindsight, I would say I was possessed. I knew that I was doing something irrevocable, something I would regret, but I was unable to stop myself.

When I finally did override my killing impulse, the cat was unconscious. It had a fleck of blood on its mouth and I realized it was too late. I had killed the cat. My most intense regret was that I had used my left hand to commit the act, because I considered it to be the hand of healing.


I took the cat outside and dropped it on the ground. It was dead. I stared at it in horror. I felt as if I had stained my soul forever. As I stared at it, the cat began to twitch. The twitches turned into convulsions. I believed I was watching its death throes.

Then something strange occurred. The convulsions became so intense that the cat jerked upright, and then began to stagger around.

It was like watching a film in reverse, was the thought I had at the time; as if I was seeing time going backwards. The more it jerked and staggered about, the more coordinated its movements became. Within a few seconds, it was moving normally, and then it dashed away.

I had no doubt I had witnessed—even somehow caused—a miraculous resurrection event. It felt as if my remorse had caused energy to flow out of me and reanimate the cat. I thanked God for the reprieve, and that I would not have cat murder on my conscience forever (only attempted cat murder).

The next night, the cat came back looking for food again. I left it alone.


Just today (November 15th, 2026), it occurred to me that my territoriality around the food in my house (the cat had been eating my food as well) had a curious echo in my past.

As an adolescent, I developed a habit of taking wedges of cheddar cheese (and sometimes bread) to my bedroom, and eating them with crisps while reading Marvel comics. This was a dangerous routine in our house, however, because my mother (who enforced almost zero discipline in any other way) had a violent objection to what she called “eating between meals” (snacking).

Whenever she caught me in her kitchen on such a mission, she would invariably explode. Consequently, I would tiptoe downstairs, be as silent as possible gathering my snack, and sneak back to my bedroom, all the while in a state of high alertness for sounds of her approach.

On a particularly memorable occasion, she caught me by surprise and came blazing into the kitchen. I stood frozen, a deer in the headlights of her fury. She screamed at me: “No wonder you don’t have any friends!!”

I was probably twelve at the time. The grim irony is that my snacking habit (besides being the perfectly natural appetite of growing lad) was a symptom of anxiety caused by living alone with an alcoholic and irrationally volatile mother. Snacking in this way was a self-medicating refuge (to this day, I still enjoy eating crisps while watching movies or reading).

At that time, I had two or three close friends, and it was news to me that this was less than the requisite amount—never mind that my snack-eating was the cause of it.

Talk about crazy making.


Perhaps the ginger cat in Guatemala was a stand-in for my adolescent self, sneaking into my kitchen to steal food? Which would mean the rage I was possessed by was my mother’s. At the same time, perhaps my own unexpressed rage against her was coming out? If so, I was both embodying my mother’s desire to strangle me, and acting out my suppressed desire to strangle her, on a relatively innocent feline.

In both cases, the “crime” was the same: taking food in order to satisfy a natural hunger—about as basic a need as it gets. Similarly, territorial violence is in many ways the most basic form of violence: reacting against a sense of boundaries being violated—as mine certainly were by my mother, even as she reacted as if I was violating hers.


(Part two of this tale, the good part, is behind this Paywall. Part one was provided to you by paying subscribers.)