The Joy of Impermanency
A Philosophic Confessional
“What was that about hats again?” —Monty Python, The Meaning of Life 1
Two Lists
Everything that is will soon cease to be, leaving no visible traces.
Soon relative to eternity, that is. The Sun will be around quite a bit longer than the rest of us; but it too will pass away.
The list of things that will cease to be is a very long one, effectively infinite. Starting and ending with yourself, the Alpha and Omega of impermanency.
We came from nowhere, soon to return there. Traces will remain, but only for a time.
The list of things that will not cease to be is a very short one, effectively infinitesimal. God, Christ, Buddha-Nature, Sat-Chit-Ananda, being, consciousness, bliss.
That which we truly are, when everything else is gone.
Gone
That everything and everyone we care about is destined for complete and utter annihilation does not seem like glad tidings. More like a bald and horrifying fact that leads inexorably to nihilism.
Nihilists, including my brother, would say faith, religious belief, the ideas of God and the afterlife, are all just coping mechanisms in the face of the one thing that is certain: that death conquers all and nothing lasts forever.
Yet here we are.
If nothing lasts, how come there’s always something here? After all, things have been impermanent since the beginning of time.
Yet what gives rise to all this fleeting phenomena clearly never ceases to do so, otherwise it would surely have ceased a long, long time ago, leaving no more phenomena.
The longest possible stretch of time is a blip in eternity. The life of a gnat that gets stuck in your eye is no more fleeting than all of human history.
Undead
What within us can sense impermanency?
We cannot perceive our mortality, for to do so, we would have to be dead. And as Paul Bowles once said, “Dead is the one thing we can never be” (for to die is to cease to be).
What is impermanent cannot experience its impermanency.
To have a realization of our impermanency is impossible because the realization itself is impermanent, no more than a fleeting image.
The thought, “The only constant is change” changes instantly into another thought, in which we no longer know if it is true or not. After all, that constant also may change.
Strictly speaking, we cannot even conceive of our impermanency as anything but a concept, an abstract proposition. We do not believe we will ever really die, because, as Woody Allen wistfully put it, we will not be there when it happens.
The thought, “I am dying” cannot ever become “I am dead” without turning into “Holy shit. I am still here!” Not so impermanent as we thought!
An Unscratchable Itch
In the face of impermanency, we crave some sort of reassurance, a way to affirm our existence, to leave a mark in time that will last. We seek the affirmation of our being.
God is the only thing that can give us such affirmation; but since we can’t apply directly to God in heaven about our issue (ask Job), we seek the next best thing: our father’s blessing, on earth.
Or our mother’s.
Picture an infant in its crib, left there for safe-keeping while the mother goes off to the drinks cabinet and pours herself a G & T; or to the bedroom, for some afternoon delight; or off to town, to do some shopping. “Baby will be fine for an hour or two.”
But the baby isn’t fine. It wakes, calls out for its mama, its dadda, and finds only silence, and cold, dark emptiness. “Father, mother, why have you abandoned me?”
It can’t even conceive this question. It knows only bottomless longing, craving, desperation, despair, early saṅkhāra, formative imprints. The scar on the soul, the wound that never heals.
Sixty years later, baby is now a man—still seeking attention, still feeling like his life depends on getting it, on getting likes, bringing men to the men’s meeting, being interviewed on podcasts, having his books reviewed, praised, admired.
On having his existence affirmed in the face of impermanency.
Eventually, after decades of failing to scratch that itch, impermanency starts to seem like a blessing and not a curse. This is all passing anyway, so what’s the difference?
He could be Carlos Castaneda, worshipped by millions, and the Eagle would still devour him in the end.